Yeninko of the Umlaut

Tuesday, October 03, 2006

A Nice Point

From profwhat on a story about Athism in America

"I believe that the vast majority of Americans are functional atheists, even though they tell themselves and others that they do believe in God.

A "functional atheist" is someone who acts exactly as an atheist would. He does not go to church. He has ethics and morals, but they are based on many considerations other than what the Bible says. When he decides what he thinks about abortion, gay marriage, or contraception, he forms his opinion without serious consultation with religious beliefs. In fact, if he finds that his church has begun to disagree with his views on one of those issues, he might change religions and belong to a church that agrees with him. He might give to charity, but more because he believes in that cause rather than because he believes God has commanded him to be charitable. He doesn't celebrate any religious holidays, beyond exchanging presents at Christmas and taking Mom to brunch on Easter. If his religion requires him not to eat certain foods, he eats them anyway; if he is required to tithe, he doesn't; if he is required to stop working on a certain day, he checks his Blackberry. If his religion tells him something about how the world was made or works and that contradicts what science now tells us, he'll either believe the science or refuse to confront the question. At no point does he let his religion stand in the way of what he wants to do, or how he wants to act. Other than what's going on in this guy's head, is there any reason not to call this guy an atheist?"

2 Comments:

  • Well, you ask if there is any reason not to call these people atheists. There is; they are agnostic, not atheist.

    Atheism always strikes me funny. Strongly believing in disproving something shows some kind of weird inferiority complex. It's almost like atheists are jealous that religions get so much attention.

    Good tips on buying a first bike, by the way.
    -Bones

    By Blogger Bones, at 6:44 AM  

  • In response bones, I'd actually agree. I am jealous that religion gets so much attention.

    I don’t think it’s inferiority complex (really, hearing most atheist it is quite the opposite, we feel bad for people who believe in the lands of make believe), it has more to do with how much sway religion seems to have over secular issues. For example the brouhaha over gay marriage or extramarital sex, etc. As if believing one of various provable postulations somehow makes you more of a reliable resource for information or morality. That kind of attention IS irritating. It would seem that a Good Christian bank robber has more credibility in this day and age than an atheist social worker.

    By Blogger Yen, at 9:33 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home